Connect with us

Entertainment

Fyre: Two Documentaries Tell a Very Different Story

Read about the infamous Fyre Festival and the two documentaries that are telling the story.

Avatar

Published

on

As streaming services start to replace traditional film and TV production companies, a battle for viewership is breaking out. The latest contenders? Hulu vs. Netflix. 

Last week, Netflix was set to release its documentary Fyre about the 2017 Fyre Festival that became the scam to end all scams. But on Monday Hulu’s own version of the festival story called Fyre Fraud got an early release. So, the question remains, who did it better?

First, let’s back up. If you’ve never heard of the infamous Fyre Festival, then congratulations you’re in for a wild story. The Fyre Festival was supposed to be the ultimate music festival — think Coachella but ten times more luxurious and exclusive. And little-known fact: the festival was actually a promotion for the accompanying Fyre app, a talent booking software that was supposed to be like the Uber of the talent booking industry. The festival was going to take place Pablo Escobar’s private island in the Bahamas where there would be two weekends of music (Blink 182 and Major Lazer were both set to come), gourmet food, private jets, luxury beachfront villas, and the party of a lifetime all for the reasonable price range of $5,000 to $250,000. 

With expectations high, attendees showed up to the first weekend of the festival in April 2018 to find hurricane shelters set up in the backyard of a Sandals Resort. (Yikes.) What went wrong? The Netflix and Hulu productions went to find out.

While some comparative reviews of the documentaries will tell you that the films are basically the same, there are quite a few major differences. The first noticeable differences are the way that the stories are portrayed. Hulu calls their documentary a “true-crime comedy,” which is what really caused the film to miss the mark in my opinion. In an attempt to reflect all the ridiculous memery (yes, that is now a word) that surrounded the failure of the festival, Hulu frequently inserted clips from popular TV shows in between scenes, at one point comparing two of the festival’s manufacturers to Michael Scott and Dwight Schrute and comparing the company Magnisus (we’ll get to that in a second) to Tom Haverford’s hilarious business venture Entertainment 720. The film’s ending sequence rolled out to a crescendoing rendition of “Build Me Up Buttercup,” which left me cringing in front of my computer screen.

With this light-hearted take on what could have been a pretty a serious disaster, Hulu managed to use this documentary to blame everything on millennials. (Insert eye roll here). The cutting cultural commentary of the film was that if millennials weren’t so motivated by FOMO, Instagram, and supermodels, then this never would’ve happened in the first place. (Florals? For spring? Groundbreaking.)

But this could not be further from the truth. From Woodstock to Burning Man to Live Aid to Coachella, music festivals like this have always been popular. And, as one interviewee pointed out in Netflix’s documentary, attendees at Woodstock experienced mudslides, drug overdoses, and lack of food and water, but it’s in the history books as an iconic cultural event of the time. How did Woodstock survive all of this bad PR? Well, because there was no social media.

The one redeeming quality of the documentary is it explored the “weaponization of social media”. (And you’ll see why Netflix was unable to do this in a minute .) Hulu really showed the way in which one charismatic man (although I personally found him pathetically delusional) was able to defraud millennials with the support of influencers, such as Bella Hadid and Kendall Jenner.   

On the flip side, Netflix’s film was branded as a serious, hard-hitting investigation into the festival. It was more cohesive than Hulu’s version; however, as a viewer I felt the film often didn’t answer the right questions, making it at times over-dramatized and insincere. Unlike the Hulu documentary, many of the interviewees in Netflix’s Fyre — which included employees of the festival, members of the marketing team, and festival attendees, to name a few — seemingly refused to take any responsibility for the failure of the festival, despite the numerous red flags that led up to the event. If you want a basic summary of the denial that took place in the film look no further than this unsolicited tweet from Ja Rule, who became the face of the festival.

This very different take on the festival can be attributed to the fact that Jerry Media, the marketing firm that was hired to create the buzz around the Fyre Festival, was also a producer for the Netflix documentary. (Gasp. I didn’t realize this until Hulu threw major shade during their own documentary.) This huge lapse in journalistic integrity explains why all of those involved in the making of the festival went pretty easy on themselves and played the victim — not say that there weren’t any victims. (Note: A former Jerry Media employee was interviewed in the Hulu documentary and expressed a lot of uncertainty and subsequent remorse in the company’s participation in the festival.)

Fyre was the brain child of a man named Billy MacFarland, who had made a name for himself in New York City starting a social club called Magnisus, whose membership came with a black metal credit card. MacFarland played a major character in both documentaries, for obvious reasons, but more so in Hulu’s film which featured an exclusive interview the now-incarcerated mastermind behind the project. The big catch to this was: a) MacFarland just spends most of the interview uncomfortably squirming in front of the camera repeating the answers his lawyers probably told him to memorize and b) Hulu actually PAID MacFarland to do the interview! (Double gasp.) In conclusion, neither of these docs has a squeaky clean record in the integrity department.

What really surprised me was that both films failed to go into the real tragedy of the whole Fyre fiasco. (And no, it wasn’t that a bunch of social media influencers plus a few hundred other people spent their last thousand dollars to sleep in a FEMA shelter and eat a cheese sandwich.) Although Netflix dug into this issue a little more than Hulu, neither film investigated nearly enough into the failed festival’s exploitation of the hundreds of Bahamian workers who were never paid. (Although a GoFundMe has been set up and reached its goal for the restaurant owner in Netflix’s documentary who tearfully revealed that she had spent $50,000 of her own money undoing the damage that the festival had left behind.)

Together these two films give a more complete story of the series of events that led to the massive failure that was the Fyre Festival. But, separately, they tell two different accounts: one, a comical cultural comment on the lengths that millennials will go to “do it for the ‘gram” and, the other, a tale of epic tragedy — but mostly for the white people.

All in all there still seems to be a lot of unanswered questions about the Fyre Festival, which just goes to show that when you fight fyre with fyre, nobody wins. (P.S. If you’re just looking for the Cliff Notes version of the Fyre Festival docs, then this YouTube video will do just as well.)

Jumpstart a career doing something you are passionate about with one of College Media Network’s courses. Read about our current offerings, schedule and unique virtual learning environment here.

Grace Cooper is a recent graduate of the University of Pittsburgh where she studied Nonfiction Writing and Psychology. When she's not obsessively reading or writing about the news, you can probably find her eating too much pizza and watching When Harry Met Sally for the hundredth time.

CMN Music

Music6 hours ago

Viewpoint: Year-End (or Decade-End) Lists are Healthy for Music Fans

At least we're having the discussion about what makes our favorite music so fantastic.

Music4 days ago

Don’t Be Stale, Mate – Try Snailmate

Nerdy, asthmatic, expulsive, and self-critical songs.

Music1 week ago

Viewpoint: Pitchfork’s Best of the Decade is Full of Pleasant Surprises

A notable balance between well-known artists and smaller independent acts.

Music2 weeks ago

Pitchfork’s 200 Best Albums of the 2010’s has Plenty of Gaps

How does one come to the conclusion that Death Grips come out just above Leonard Cohen but below Janelle Monáe?

Music4 weeks ago

Album Review: Tamino – ‘Amir (Deluxe)’

An expanded edition that offers poetic drama from beginning to end.

Music1 month ago

What Makes A Scary Song? Three Things Every Spooky Tune Needs

Genuinely scary sounds, an unsettling story, or just party jams with eerie sound effects?

Music2 months ago

React: Paste Magazine’s Best Albums of the 2010’s List

It's difficult for any one person to approach a list with complete objectivity,

CMN Vibes2 months ago

CMN Vibes: Spooky Season

The only playlist you'll need as Halloween gets closer.

Music2 months ago

4 Places to Read Great Music Journalism

Where to find great, free music writing and journalism on the web.

Essentials3 months ago

Four Useful Spotify Features for Music Writers: Part One

Tips, tricks and cool shortcuts to deepen your knowledge.

Music3 months ago

‘We’ll Carry On’: Examining the Legacy of Rock in the 2000s

The seeds planted by these bands are the reason rock will thrive for generations.

Music3 months ago

Man Arrested in Connection of Death of Rapper Mac Miller

28 year old Cameron James Pettit was arrested today on allegations of supplying deceased rapper Mac Miller with lethal drugs....

Music3 months ago

5 Things You’ll Quickly Learn After Moving From the USA to New Zealand

So you graduate college without any real career plan and decide to spend a year bartending so you can travel...

Music3 months ago

Review: Captain Beefheart, “Hair Pie: Bake 2”

An odd intrigue.

Essentials3 months ago

4 Podcasts Every Music Writer Should be Familiar With

Music journalists these days need to listen to a whole lot more than just music.

Music4 months ago

Cocaine and Rhinestones – Breaking Down Merle Haggard’s ‘Okie from Muskogee’

Tyler Mahan Coe brings the facts and the feel of history.

Music4 months ago

Track Review: Pool Kids – ‘$5 Subtweet’

Diving into a new age of confrontation.

by , SUNY Brockport
Music4 months ago

Hip-Hop’s Most Influential Artists of the Last Half -Decade

Drake, Migos, Travis Scott and more make the list.

by , SUNY Brockport
Music4 months ago

Podcast Review: The Needledrop: How To Get Into Death Grips

Dominick Rabrun joins Anthony Fantano for some intense chat.

Music4 months ago

Desert Island Disc: ‘The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill’

This album challenges misogyny, materialism and issues within relationships

Music4 months ago

Liily: Aiming to Turn the Music Industry Upside Down

California band is on the way up and has new music due out this fall.

Music4 months ago

Interview with Singer Natalie Clark

A CMN Q&A that touches on playing guitar, growing up in Glasgow, and being starstruck on 'The Voice.'

Great Reads

[]
1 Step 1
keyboard_arrow_leftPrevious
Nextkeyboard_arrow_right

Copyright © 2019 College Media Network