Connect with us

2018 Midterms

U.S. Supreme Court Sides with Colorado Baker in a Narrow Ruling

While the decision did not set a precedent, it could lead towards a slippery slope when it comes anti-discrimination laws nationwide.

Duane Paul Murphy

Published

on

On Monday, June 4, the United States Supreme Court ruled in favor of a Lakewood, Colorado baker and bakery store owner, Jack Philips, who refused to make a wedding cake for a local gay couple, David Mullins and Charlie Craig, on the grounds of his own Chrisitan religious beliefs. However, in the 7 to 2 narrow ruling, the highest court in the country did not state or indicate that all services can now refuse work or serve LGBTQIA+ couples or individuals. The legal ruling Justices Roberts, Kagan, Breyer, Gorsuch, Alito, and Thomas sided with the baker in the majority ruling while Justices Ginsburg and Sotomayor had dissenting opinions.

Writing the majority opinion, conservative-leaning Justice Anthony Kennedy, who is often known for his liberal rulings on legalizing marriage nationwide and striking down the federal Defense of Marriage Act that was passed during the Clinton Administration in the 1990s, said that the Denver based Colorado Civil Rights Commission was primarily biased against Philips and Colorado law can continue to protect LGBTQIA+ individuals and couples in purchasing or accessing public accommodated goods or services if it is “neutral toward religion”.

While this particular ruling puts anti-discrimination laws on edge, a variety of states nationwide have enacted anti-discrimination laws based on an individual’s or couple’s sexual orientation and gender identity as well as bans on conversion therapy for LGBTQIA+ youth. According to a recent 2016 public opinion poll from the Public Religion Research Institute in Washington, D.C.,  71% of Americans surveyed support laws protecting LGBTQIA+ people from discrimination and 59% oppose any business allowing to refuse services or products to LGBTQIA+ people based on personal religious beliefs.

Did you enjoy this article? Consider supporting College Media Network's mission to support the next generation of journalists. For as little as $2 a month, you can help keep our site ad-free and the future of journalism alive. Go here to donate.

Duane Paul Murphy is a D.C. college student and student journalist born and raised in Southern California. Currently studying for his bachelor’s in politics and a minor in media studies, Duane Paul is interested in covering domestic as well as international political affairs that impact the lives of everyday people, whether they are young students, professionals, or faculty in higher education.

Sign up for the Morning Scoop

and wake up with us each day.

CMN Reports

National News19 hours ago

Trump Is Changing the Colors of Air Force One

Because the Kennedy's were not patriotic enough, right?

by , Senior Editor
National News21 hours ago

American University on Lockdown

American University is on lockdown after armed man is reported near campus.

by , American University
Equality2 days ago

10 Black Washington University Students Falsely Accused of Leaving IHOP Without Paying

"The fact that these 10 students, all of whom are African American, were scared and humiliated is unacceptable to us"...

by , American University
Academics3 days ago

Keynote Speakers Highlight Importance of Diversity at College Journalism Workshop

Some important reflections on an important topic.

by , Virginia Commonwealth University
National News4 days ago

Teen Who Urged Boyfriend’s Suicide Through Text Says It Was Free Speech

Apparently, the First Amendment extends to telling your boyfriend to get back into the truck and kill himself.

by , Penn State University
Entertainment6 days ago

Stormy Daniels ‘Set up’ in Police Sting Operations

A juicy piece of the Stormy Daniels saga.

by , Senior Editor
Entertainment7 days ago

Build-A-Bear ‘Pay Your Age’ Deal Ends in Failure

Would you wait in a line for hours, for a $29.00 teddy? Many did, which ended in chaos.

by , CMN Senior Correspondent
Entrepreneurship7 days ago

Papa John’s Founder Resigns After Using Racial Slur

Papa John's is on the search for a new face.

by , U. Alabama Birmingham

Top Reads