Connect with us

Academics

Viewpoint: Schools Must Equip Students to Navigate Alt-Right Websites That Push Fake News

Nearly 60% of America’s middle and high school students rely on alt-right internet sites as credible sources.

The Conversation

Published

on

File 20180612 112618 1420bsv.jpg?ixlib=rb 1.1

Middle and high school students turn to alt-right websites for their research papers. (Image: Steve Heap/www.shutterstock.com)

Jennifer Rich, Rowan University

More than 60 percent of America’s middle and high school students rely on alt-right internet sites as credible sources for their research papers. The students are using alt-right sites to write papers on topics that range from free speech and the Second Amendment to citizenship, immigration and the Holocaust.

These were among the key findings of a preliminary survey of 200 teachers I conducted recently to develop a snapshot of how common it was for middle and high school students to turn to alt-right websites.

As a researcher who specializes in teaching what is known as “hard histories,” including slavery, the Holocaust and other genocides, this finding is of concern, particularly as the nation approaches the one-year anniversary of the tragedy in Charlottesville, Virginia.

Who they are

The alt-right is a connected set of far-right groups, beliefs and individual people. They believe in white supremacy, and that it is under attack by multiculturalism, political correctness and social justice. It was the alt-right that marched in Charlottesville, shouting Nazi slogans and invoking the KKK. One way the alt-right recruits new members is through social media and other online platforms.

Despite the link between the alt-right and the Charlottesville tragedy, students are still using alt-right websites for their research papers in school, according to teachers I surveyed in New Jersey, Pennsylvania and New York. The teachers reported that the students cite these websites in their bibliographies but often struggle to make sense of the information they obtained from the sites.

These sites are increasingly prominent. In fact, it is interesting to note that the alt-right websites teachers list as being used most often by their students have all been started since 2005, with the exception of one, and many have come into existence in just the past five years.

Examining alt-right websites

The question becomes, then, what should teachers do regarding these sites? Is it the responsibility of teachers to actually do anything?

Instead of ignoring these sites, I’d suggest teachers might do best to teach students how to critically examine the sites. In order to do that, however, teachers must know what is out there. While this is not an exhaustive list, the following six alt-right websites were most commonly cited by teachers as those that students use for their papers.

They are: National Policy Institute, Radix Journal, American Renaissance, Taki’s Magazine and Voat.

In open-ended follow-up questions, teachers added that students find the information on these sites appealing but are unable to differentiate between fact and fiction.

In classroom spaces, teachers will inevitably teach students who come from a variety of backgrounds and who hold different beliefs, ideas and opinions. Still, it is a teacher’s job to encourage objective, fact-based thinking to the students in their care. Awareness of pseudo-scientific “White identity” sites like Radix and American Renaissance allows teachers to deconstruct those sites with students, encourage critical reading, and debate the validity and value of the content.

Uncomfortable subject matter

Teachers responding to my survey report that they are uncomfortable teaching about these websites because they are certain they have “at least some” students who agree with the alt-right sites in question. The teachers also believe that teaching about these websites in class would lead to uncomfortable conversations.

As teachers, it is not our job to indoctrinate students to think as we do. However, it is our job to teach facts. Creating a safe classroom climate will allow for these uncomfortable conversations where close examinations of the opinions presented on these websites can be examined in a dispassionate way. For example, Radix Journal recently featured an article that “Martin Luther King Jr., a fraud and degenerate in his life, has become the symbol and cynosure of White Dispossession and the deconstruction of European civilization.” It is reasonable to expect heated student disagreement around an article like this one. This, then, opens up space to teach students how to engage in respectful and difficult conversations with one another.

Lessons of this sort would certainly involve countering misinformation that is put forward on these sites. For example, after looking at the Radix Journal article that attacks Martin Luther King Jr., it would be appropriate to have students consider “Three Visions for Achieving Equal Rights,” a lesson with primary sources from the organization Facing History and Ourselves. Beyond this point-counterpoint, students need to be given tools to evaluate the validity of the information they encounter while doing research. One excellent tool to do this, “Evaluating Online Resources,” comes from the project Teaching Tolerance, and helps students evaluate online sources. Regardless of the resource used, students need to be pushed to consider who the author is, his or her bias, and the purpose of the article.

What I am suggesting here might engender pushback but so did other proposals to introduce controversial subjects to students. Consider sex education in the 1960s or the DARE program in the 1980s. Today, both are commonplace in schools, despite the idea that they expose students to controversial information they might not know, including information about safe sex and different drugs.

Why it’s necessary

Fewer than 10 percent of teachers report doing any whole class teaching about, or discussion of, these alt-right websites, despite the fact that more than half of their students utilize these sites, according to responses to my survey. Instead, they speak to students individually and request that they find other sources, according to my survey.

The ConversationTeachers need to help students learn to recognize credible sources and not fall victim to alt-right sites that put forth propaganda. In order to combat the darkness in the world and on the web, teachers must have the knowledge and courage to teach about it directly.

Jennifer Rich, Assistant Professor, Rowan University. This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Are you looking to get more experience in digital media? Join the CMN team as a writer or social media producer and get real-time experience, intense feedback on your writing and a great place to display your work.You can get academic credit, too. Check out our current opportunities here.

Sign up for the Morning Scoop

and wake up with us each day.

CMN Reports

Equality6 days ago

Truett McConnell University Cuts Ties With Nike After Kaepernick Commercial

They're on that Christian college trend.

by , University of Kentucky
Government1 week ago

Analysis: Trump Administration Still Wants to Separate Immigrant Families

The Flores settlement is in the spotlight as children remain apart from their parents.

by , College of the Holy Cross
Campus Crime2 weeks ago

Here’s What to Know About the Trump Administration’s New Sexual Assault Guidelines

Hint: it's a lot of semantics.

by , College of the Holy Cross
National News2 weeks ago

Toyota Recalls Over One Million or More Hybrids Due to Fire Risk

Toyota is under pressure after over a million vehicles were recalled.

by , CMN Senior Correspondent
Entertainment3 weeks ago

Hacker Who Published Celebrities’ Nude Photos Sentenced to Jail

Garofano was the first out of four people to be sentenced for these crimes.

by , CMN Senior Correspondent
National News3 weeks ago

Delta Sigma Theta Members Honor Late Soror, Aretha Franklin

Thousands gather to pay their respects to the Queen of Soul

by , U. Alabama Birmingham
Free Speech3 weeks ago

Creator of 3D-Printed Guns is Selling Blueprints, Despite Court Rulings

Loopholes make all the difference sometimes...

by , CMN Senior Correspondent
Campus Crime3 weeks ago

Seven Arrested in Protests Over Removal of “Silent Sam” at UNC Chapel Hill

Protests over the removal of a confederate statue at UNC Chapel Hill on Monday come to a head this Saturday.

by , College of Charleston

Top Reads