Connect with us


Which Rookie QB Will Start Week 1?

Rookie QBs struggle to make their mark, but one looks set to start the season.

Tom Spurling



Baker Mayfield throws during the Cleveland Browns training camp (Image: Wikimedia Commons)

With the NFL preseason underway, fans and coaches now have their first live acton look at the players they drafted just months ago. A position possibly scrutinized more than any other during the early parts of the NFL season is the quarterback position.

Drafting a quarterback in the first or second rounds creates the assumption that he will be the week one starter for that team. However, this years draft class has coaches proceeding with a bit more caution than usual.

Developing Mayfield 

Number one overall pick Baker Mayfield impressed in his first NFL game playing for the Browns, throwing for over 200 yards and completing a touchdown pass.

By the standards of Cleveland fans, who have watched their team finish last in the AFC North repeatedly over the years (and lose every game last season), Mayfield’s stat line sounds pretty good. However, the performance that starting QB Tyrod Taylor put together can’t be ignored as he went a perfect 5/5 with a touchdown in his limited reps.

It is too early to tell whether Mayfield is ready to take the reigns in Ohio, but head coach Hue Jackson seems determined to allow this young quarterback to develop behind Taylor for the time being. The Browns have plenty of up and coming talent but don’t seem quite ready to use it yet.

Darnold Trending Upwards

Sam Darnold has perhaps the tallest hill to climb among rookie quarterbacks this season, as he currently sits behind former first rounder Teddy Bridgewater and established vet Josh McCown. Against those odds, it may be his competition to lose in New York after an impressive showcase against 1st string talent last week.

Darnold went 13 for 18, and led his team on an impressive 2-minute drill drive that resulted in a touchdown to end the first half. McCown has always been the temporary starter while Darnold developed his game and Bridgwater healed his knee, but it looks like Darnold may be ready for week one.

With the history of injuries former Viking Bridgewater brings with him, it looks like Darnold will play his way right into the AFC East QB conversation.

Unfortunate For Allen 

Buffalo Bills rookie quarterback Josh Allen has found himself in an unfortunate situation just months into his NFL career.

Currently teetering between second and third on the depth chart, Allen will have to perform above and beyond to earn the starting role week one. When the bills acquired former Bengal A.J. McCarron this offseason, most assumed he was set to become the Bills franchise QB. By drafting Allen, the Bills added security on their depth chart and the presence of competition at the QB position.

Currently the biggest competition in Buffalo is for backup quarterback and it is between Allen and Nathan Peterman.


The Baltimore Ravens have had Joe Flacco at the helm of their offense for as long as the Ravens have been relevant. But as his health declines and his accuracy continues to underwhelm, the Ravens must look at other options behind center.

The team drafted Heisman Trophy winner Lamar Jackson out of Louisville. Primarily a mobile quarterback, Jackson has drawn comparisons to Michael Vick in his running style. Although he doesn’t have the strongest arm out of the rookie quarterbacks, his sheer athleticism make his coaches hopeful he can bring Baltimore back to what it was in recent seasons.

Ever wished you could start a career covering your favorite sport? Have you spent time wishing you could combine your love of sports with your passion for writing and reporting? CMN’s Sports Journalism course is an experiential learning program designed to give the practical experience you need to get your foot in the door in this ultra-competitive industry. You’ll get useful, direct feedback on your reporting, exposure to experienced sports journalists and influencers, and a great place to build your portfolio. You can get college credit, too. Get all the details on the CMN's Sports Journalism Course here.

Tom is a student at Fisher College in Boston. Tom spends his time conquering video games and exploring his city of Boston. His favorite part of writing is the stories and hopes to tell them for years to come.

Sign up for the Morning Scoop

and wake up with us each day.

CMN Reports

National News4 hours ago

CNN is Requesting an Emergency Hearing after Trump Administration Threatens to Revoke Acosta’s Press Pass Again

CNN file a lawsuit against President Trump

by , Mercy College
History3 days ago

Judge Rules CNN’s Jim Acosta Must be Granted Previous Press Credentials

A win for journalistic the saga continues.

by , CMN Senior Correspondent
2018 Midterms1 week ago

New York Governor Andrew Cuomo Wins a Third Term

Many government officials from New York were reelected and new faces were elected into government in Tuesday's Midterm Election.

by , Mercy College
2018 Midterms2 weeks ago

Electoral Reform and Voting Rights Expansion Won Big in the Midterms

From Florida to Michigan, voting rights expansions and electoral reform are making gains.

by , The Catholic American University
National News2 weeks ago

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg Hospitalized After Fracturing Ribs in a Fall

The Supreme Court Justice fell in the office on Wednesday night

by , Cal Poly SLO
Academics2 weeks ago

Analysis: Adolescent Mental Health Issues are on the Rise and Gun Violence is to Blame

Children are rightfully beginning to fear going to school because of the massive amount of school shootings within recent years.

by , The College of New Jersey
Health3 weeks ago

First FDA Approved Cannabis-Based Drug Available for Prescription

CBD has been known to treat seizures for years, but now the FDA is on board, making it legal for...

by , CMN Senior Correspondent
Government3 weeks ago

Multiple Suspicious Devices Sent to Prominent People in the Democratic Party

Several devices sent to various locations within a few days.

by , Mercy College

Top Reads